Blog » Post

Lib Dems turn down coalition offer

May 6th 2007 21:50. Updated: May 6th 2007 22:20

…for the time being?

According to the BBC, the Liberal Democrats are refusing to go into coalition with the SNP for the time being. The stumbling block is, of course, the independence referendum.

I am quite surprised. As the campaign went along, both the Lib Dems and the SNP seemed to be leaving wriggle room for compromise. To suddenly shut the door on a deal is surprising.

This is the second time in less than twelve hours that the Lib Dems have ruled out a coalition deal. Tavish Scott was on The Politics Show this afternoon and when he was asked if a coalition deal with Labour was on the cards he said confidently and without hesitation, “No.”

Perhaps the Lib Dems have figured that they have nothing to gain from making another coalition deal. They are getting a bad reputation from voters, who are increasingly seeing the Lib Dems as political prostitutes.

Maybe they have decided the best course of action is just to go away and lick their wounds after all. And they will now score brownie points for sticking to their guns and refusing to sell out on the question of independence.

Still, I’m sure this isn’t the end of it. Nicol Stephen might have made a rash decision. Maybe Alex Salmond raised the stakes too high by trying to secure a proper referendum on independence, rather than more powers for Holyrood or a multi-question referendum.

A lot of people have talked about “confidence and supply” over the past few days, and that did sound like a feasible option.

I guess the bottom line is that the election was just far too close for any solution to be allowed to come about. As things stand, Scottish politics is in total gridlock. Things are even too tight to choose the Presiding Officer. And with the Lib Dems refusing to go into coalition with anyone, a re-election really is on the cards.

Via Mr Eugenides.

Update: The BBC story has been expanded a bit now.

“I made it clear to him that unless and until the SNP removes the fundamental barrier of a referendum on independence during the next four years, there can be no coalition,” Mr Stephen added in a statement.

I guess not much has changed, except that the ball is firmly in Alex Salmond’s court. Is he prepared to remove that “fundamental barrier”? It would enrage SNP activists.

Rate: No votes yet
Loading ... Loading ...

4 Comments »

Comments RSS feed
Trackback URL

  1. #1 Richard Havers Gravatar
    May 6th 2007 22:30

    The Lib Dems have nothing to gain politically other than jobs for the boys from a coalition with the SNP. But that won’t stop ‘em if the deal is right. We all know they are not THAT principled.

    It’s all going to get very messy. Of course the country will chunter along proving, as if we didn’t already know it, that sleepy Holyrood is an unnecessary expense!

    Mind you if there is a multi question referendum will anyone understand it enough to be able to answer any of what’s put to them?

    Question 1

    Alex Salmond, former First Minister, who will now be President of the best small country in the world (and should we have our own embassies or just rent a back room from the English?) as long as you put a cross by this question. p.s. Shall we keep the Queen as Head of State or shall we let the old firm play in the English Premiership?

  2. #2 Vicky Gravatar
    May 7th 2007 12:29

    The SNP are going to have a tough job ahead of them - I don’t know about minority administrations in the UK, but Canada (not a dissimilar system to the UK) has had a fair few in its history and none have survived a full term.

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, name and email required, email never displayed, HTML allowed.